Fluffernutter

The Sunday Shake Shack flavor for March is Fluffernutter. We were very intrigued by this as A loves peanut butter, and he's heard that marshmallow fluff is delicious. People are always espousing on the amazingness of the combination, but we've never had the opportunity to try it. Yes, amazingness isn't a word. So what? Such as it is, we were excited to try this flavor, but we were also a little apprehensive since the peanut butter flavors in the past for Shake Shack have been underwhelming at best.

Fluffernutter
This custard was interesting in that it seemed like vanilla custard blended with crunchy peanut butter and supposedly marshmallow flavoring. It definitely had peanut butter, but it really didn't taste of any sort of marshmallow. The peanuts added a nice crunchiness. At one point A thought he saw a piece of marshmallow actually mixed in, but he couldn't taste it. M mostly thought it tasted like a sweet peanut butter. She didn't get any peanuts or marshmallow pieces, just swirls of peanut butter. The best part to M was that it soothed her sore throat. Overall it was an okay flavor, but it wasn't anything outstanding.

Fluffernutter
A's Rating: 6/10
M's Rating: 6/10